|
Course Description: The archaeology of Palestine (Israel,
occupied territories, Jordan) has a long tradition, due largely
to European and American biblical and colonial interests.
Archaeological remains are important in today's Israel and
the Palestinian territories especially because of potential
links to the Bible. The goals of this course are to provide
an overview of the history of archaeological fieldwork, the
changing methods of research in Palestine, and the culture
history of the area from prehistory to Islamic times.
This course includes pre-Biblical periods since Palestine
is one of the earliest regions in the world where the transition
from hunting and gathering modes of living to sedentary societies
took place. Remains from later prehistoric periods are of
equal importance for the understanding of urbanization and
the social, political and economic development of complex
societies.
With the Late Bronze/ Iron Ages, beginning in the later 2nd
millennium B.C.E., we enter the periods traditionally thought
to be recounted in the Bible. In this connection, we will
deal with the question of the discrepancies between the archaeological
record and the Bible. Can the Biblical accounts be substantiated
by archaeological finds? Where is the Bible contradicted by
archaeological data? Do we have to read the Bible differently
because of archaeological research results? Are the archaeological
remains insignificant in comparison to the much more elaborate
written sources? These questions are at the core of controversies
and heated debates. They concern the times of King David,
Solomon, the Babylonian exile as well as the Roman occupation
of Palestine, the figure of Jesus and the famous "Qumran
rolls".
Format: Lecture and discussion.
Textbooks and other Literature:
Four books have been ordered for this course at the University
Bookstore.
Mazar, Amihai
1990 Archaeology of the Land of the Bible. 10,000-586
B.C.E. New York: Doubleday.
Finkelstein, Israel and Neil A. Silberman
2001 The Bible Unearthed. Archaeology's New Vision
of Ancient Israel and the Origin of its Sacred Text. New York:
The Free Press.
Bartlett, John R., ed.
1997 Archaeology and Biblical Interpretation. London:
Routledge.
Hanson, K.C. and Douglas E. Oakman
1998 Palestine in the Time of Jesus. Social Structures
and Social Conflicts. Minneapolis: Fortress Press.
A note on the content of these books: Mazar's book is an in-depth
treatment of all except the late periods, has a lot of illustrations
and should be read for a factual overview. Finkelstein and
Silberman's new book on the Iron Age is a highly critical
synthesis of early Israel, its history and archaeology. The
essays in Bartlett's volume look at controversial issues of
Biblical and New Testament times from several perspectives.
Finally, Hanson and Oakman offer an unusual perspective on
the times of Jesus, including archaeological research results.
We will read substantial portions of these books, and discuss
some of the illustrations in Mazar's volume, so I urge you
to purchase them and bring them along to classes when assigned
for readings. All other assigned readings are on reserve in
the Bartle Library's Reserve Room except for the Bible, which
we will use sometimes. It would be appropriate to have a Bible
at hand for this course. Bartle Library has copies which you
can consult if you do not have your own.
All reading assignments must be completed BEFORE the
class day for which they are assigned. I expect you to be
familiar with the readings and to be able to participate in
class discussions based upon them. If you have difficulties
with the readings or with any of the material presented in
class, be sure to ask questions.
In case some terms in the readings seem unfamiliar to you,
consult
a) for Biblical terms: the Anchor Bible Dictionary (ed.
D.N. Freedman, 1992)
b) for archaeological sites: the New Encyclopedia of Archaeological
Excavations in the Holy Land (4 vols.), ed. E. Stern,
Jerusalem 1993.
Both are available in the reference room of the library.
Finally, there are vivid literary accounts of Biblical periods:
- of life at the time of Solomon (and David) in Stefan Heym's
King David Report (latest reprint from 1997). This fascinating,
extremely well written and well researched book interweaves
political constraints of writing (hi)story with the personal
story of a writer in ancient Israel.
- of the Jewish revolt against the Roman domination in the
first century A.D., in Lion Feuchtwanger's The Jewish War
(translation from 1932).
Grades:
Your grade for the course will be based on a combination of
assignments, two exams, and a project:
|
|
There will be two exams:
Wednesday, October 8
Friday, December 12
Each exam will be worth 25% of your grade. Make-ups for
exams will only be given in case of emergency such as
severe illness. You must notify me prior to the beginning
of the exam (office no: (607) 777 2542). |
|
|
From time to time, there will be short in-class
or take-home assignments. In-class assignments will be
based on readings and/or the previous class. Such assignments
can consist of one single question or a short quiz with
several multiple choice questions. You will have 5 to
10 minutes to answer these. Quizzes will give you the
opportunity to check how well you understand the course
material. These assignments make up 15% of your grade.
They will always be handed out at the very beginning of
classes. Therefore, make sure to be in time for class.
|
|
|
Finally, you will do a project for which
you will analyze a site of your own choosing from ancient
Palestine. You should consult the "New Encyclopedia
of Archaeological Excavations in the Holy Land" to
select a site. Then consult with me at the latest by Friday,
October 17th about your choice. The goal of the papers
is to have an in-depth familiarity with one particular
site and its historical and archaeological importance.
In the process of working on it, you will also gain better
insight into archaeological research, from the material
remains excavated to the interpretation. |
Your paper should have approximately the following structure:
1) A personal account about why you chose to write
about a particular site. This part must be at least 1/2 page
long, formulated in the first person, and be personal.
2) A general description of the site, including geographical
and historical setting
3) Who excavated the site and when?
4) A chronology of the architectural remains
5) A description of the most important building and its context
6) A general description of one important kind of artifacts
(such as pottery, figurines, statuary, jewelry)
7) A general mention of other kinds of artifacts found
8) Biblical or other (Assyrian, Egyptian etc.) references
to the site
9) Bibliography: at least 10 entries that are NOT websites,
all citations must be in anthropological style.
10) Selected illustrations (copies from books of relevant
plans, features, items). Use at least five of them, up to
15. These are important and may improve your grade if well
chosen.
Select readings indicated in the Encyclopedia for research
on the above sections. The Encyclopedia bibliographies are
almost all abbreviations. A list of what these abbreviations
mean can be found in each of the 4 volumes.
A first version of your paper is due on Monday, November
10 which you will get back with my comments. No comments
will be given for papers that I receive after this deadline.
The second version, revised according to my comments, is due
on Wednesday, December 3. Papers must have a length
of at least 12 pages, double spaced, bibliography
and illustrations excluded. Bibliographies, however,
will contribute to your grade. Late papers will be penalized:
each day beyond the deadline results in one notch down from
the original grade (for example, from B to B-). The project
is worth 35% of your course grade.
NOTE: Cheating and plagiarism - the misrepresentation
of work as one's own which is not - are forms of academic
dishonesty that are punishable through university regulations.
If you have questions about what constitutes cheating or plagiarism,
see the University Rules and Expectations, ask someone
in the Writing Center, or speak to me. Especially in your
papers, any direct quote from a publication must be in quotation
marks (limit such quotations to no more than 2 lines!) and
any paraphrased material must have a reference to the relevant
readings.
- Harpur College has a rule according to which you automatically
fail a course if you miss more than 25 % of all classes. I
take this rule very seriously. No exceptions will be made.
Class Schedule
Wednesday, September 3: Introduction to the Course
Friday, September 5: The geography of Palestine
Readings:
- Rast, Walter E., 1992: Through the Ages in Palestinian Archaeology.
Philadelphia: Trinity Press. Read Chapter 2 (page 16-32).
- Mazar, Chapter 1, pages 1-9
Monday, September 8: Introduction to archaeological methods
I
Readings:
- Mazar, Chapter 1, pages 21-33.
Wednesday, September 10: Introduction to archaeological
methods II
- Rast, - Rast, Walter E., 1992: Through the Ages in Palestinian
Archaeology. Philadelphia: Trinity Press. Read Chapters 1
and 3 (page 1-15; 33-46).
Friday, September 12: Written and material sources
Readings:
- Traill, D.A., 1995: Schliemann of Troy: Treasure and Deceit.
London: John Murray. Read pp. 1-13; 102-124.
Monday, September 15: A History of Research
Readings:
- Bartlett, Chapter 1 (page 1-19).
- Silberman, N.A., 1982: Digging for God and Country, New
York: A. Knopf. Read pp. 100-112.
Wednesday, September 17: Palaeolithic of the Levant
Readings:
- Rast, Walter, 1992: Through the Ages in Palestinian Archaeology.
Philadelphia: Trinity Press. Read Chapter 4 (pages 47-59).
Friday, September 19: The Transition from Mobile Groups
to Sedentary Villages I
Readings:
- Mazar, Chapter 2, "The Neolithic Age" (pages 38-58).
Monday, September 22: The Transition from Mobile Groups
to Sedentary Villages II
Readings:
- Banning, E.B., 1998: "The Neolithic Period: Triumphs
of Architecture, Agriculture, and Art". Near Eastern
Archaeology 61 (4): 188-237.
Wednesday, September 24: Early Hierarchical Societies:
the Chalcolithic Period
Readings:
- Mazar, Chapter 3 (pages 59-90).
Friday, September 26: Rosh Hashanah, NO CLASS ***********
Monday, September 29: Tuesday, October 2: The First Urban
Societies
Readings:
- Richard, S., 1987: "The Early Bronze Age: the Rise
and Collapse of Urbanism". Biblical Archaeologist 50:
22-44.
Wednesday, October 1: Breakdown of Urban Society and Nomadism
Readings:
- Mazar, Chapter 5 (pages 151-172).
Friday, October 3: Re-Urbanization in the 2nd Millennium
B.C.E.
Readings:
- Dever, W.G., 1987: "The Middle Bronze Age. The Zenith
of the Urban Canaanite Era". Biblical Archaeologist 50:
148-177.
Monday, October 6: Yom Kippur, NO CLASS **********
Wednesday, October 8: ********* FIRST EXAM ********
Friday, October 10: Biblical Texts and Archaeological
Remains
Readings:
- Dever, W.G. 1998: "Archaeology, Ideology, and the Quest
for an 'Ancient' or 'Biblical Israel'". Near Eastern
Archaeology 61 (1): 39-52.
Monday, October 13: Moses, a Historical Figure?
Readings:
- Marcus, Amy D. 2000: The View from Nebo. Boston: Little,
Brown & Co. Read Introduction and Chapter 2 (page 3-28;
51-77).
Wednesday, October 15: Philistines
Readings:
- Mazar, A., Read from Chapter 8 pages 295-327.
Friday, October 17: Israelite "Conquest" in
the Iron Age I: Stager's Hypothesis
Readings:
- Skim the Bible, "Book of Joshua".
- Stager, L.E. 1985: "The Archaeology of the Family in
Ancient Israel". Bulletin of the American School of Oriental
Research 260: 1-35.
Monday, October 20: Other Views on the Israelite "Conquest"
Readings:
- Bartlett, Chapter 2 (by Dever, page 20-50).
Wednesday, October 22: The United Monarchy: David's Kingdom
Readings:
- Finkelstein and Silberman, Chapter 5 (pages 123-148).
Skim: - Mazar, Chapter 9 (pages 368-402).
Friday, October 24: The Divided Monarchy: The Traditional
View
Readings:
- Mazar, Chapter 10: read pages 416-444.
Monday, October 27: The Divided Monarchy: New Research
- Finkelstein and Silberman, Chapter 7 (pages 169-195).
Wednesday, October 29: Israelite Religion and Archaeology
Readings:
- Bartlett, Chapter 3 (by A. Mayes, page 51-68).
- Dever, W.G. 1984: "Asherah, Consort of Yahweh? New
Evidence from Kuntillet Ajrud". Bulletin of the American
Schools for Oriental Research 255: 21-37.
Friday, October 31: Writing Systems in Ancient Palestine
Readings:
- Mazar, Chapter 11, pages 514-520.
Monday, November 3: Babylonian Exile and Archaeology
- Finkelstein and Silberman, Chapters 11 and 12 (pages 275-314).
Wednesday, November 5: Palestine under Persian and Hellenistic
Rule
Readings:
- Rast, Walter, 1992: Through the Ages in Palestinian Archaeology.
Philadelphia: Trinity Press. Read Chapter 11 (page 145-159).
Friday, November 7: Roman Palestine: Herodes and the Second
Temple
Readings:
- Bartlett, Chapter 5 (by B. Lalor, page 95-116).
Monday, November 10: Roman Palestine: Political Economy
********* FIRST VERSION OF PAPER DUE **********
Readings:
- Hanson and Oakman, Chapter 4, pages 99-130.
Wednesday, November 12: Roman Palestine: Social Structures
Readings:
- Hanson and Oakman, Chapter 2, pages 19-30; 51-60.
Friday, November 14: Archaeology and the Historicity of
Jesus
Readings:
- Bartlett, Chapter 6 (by S.V. Freyne, page 117-144).
Monday, November 17: The Archaeology of Qumran
Readings:
- Bartlett, Chapter 4 (Pages 67-94).
Wednesday, November 19: Problems with Qumran Rolls
Readings:
- Davies, P.R., 1988: "How Not to Do Archaeology: the
Story of Qumran". Biblical Archaeologist 51 (4): 203-207.
Friday, November 21: Archaeology of the Masada
Readings:
- Make yourself familiar with basics of: Yadin, Yigael, 1966:
Masada: Herod's Fortress and the Zealots' Last Stand. New
York: Random House.
Monday, November 24: The Masada Revolt, Archaeology and
Israeli Nationalism
Readings:
- Ben-Yehuda, N., 1995: The Masada Myth, Madison: University
of Wisconsin Press. Read pp. 27-49; 228-259.
- check also: Lion Feuchtwanger, The Jewish War (a novel).
Wednesday, November 26: NO CLASS, THANKSGIVING **********
Friday, November 28: NO CLASS, THANKSGIVING ***********
Monday, December 1: Friday, November 21: Late Roman Palestine
Readings:
- Meyers, E.M., 1988: "Early Judaism and Christianity
in the Light of Archaeology". Biblical Archaeologist
51: 69-79.
Wednesday, December 3: Byzantine Palestine
*********** FINAL VERSION OF PAPER DUE *********
Readings:
- Bartlett, Chapter 7 (by C. Dauphin, page 145-166).
Friday, December 5: The Islamic Period
Readings:
- Schick, R., 1998: "Luxuriant Legacy. Palestine in the
Early Islamic Period". Biblical Archaeologist 61 (2):
74-108.
Monday, December 8: Final Discussion
Wednesday, December 10: Review Session for Second Exam
Friday, December 12: ******** SECOND EXAM ********
|