|
SYLLABUS
ANTH 264: Cultures and Crisis
SUMMER SESSION 2003, Term 1
Binghamton University
State University of New York
Class Time: MTWRF - 2:00 pm-3:40 pm
LOCATION: SW 324
|
|
Instructor: Tom Pearson
bj92690@binghamton.edu
Office hours: Tues 12:30-1:30; Thurs.
4:00-5:00 pm& by appointment
Office Location: Dept of Anthropology, Science I, Room 114
|
|
Course Description
Real and imagined crisis is an inescapable feature of daily experience
in modern society. Crisis is commonly linked to anxieties about
control and is, thus, a central component in the formation and reproduction
of modern social orders. This course explores the cultural dynamics
of real and imagined (or perceived) crisis. Anthropological approaches
to the study of culture, change and power will be highlighted by
looking at the relationships between crisis and broader forms of
social change. Processes through which crisis is culturally shaped
and the impact of crisis on structures of order and normalcy will
be explored. It further questions how the symbolic construction
of crisis enables new forms of control, particularly forms that
establish or reproduce relations of power and inequality. Case studies
will examine crisis in terms of identity, collective memory, capitalism,
colonialism, nuclearism and militarism, disease and health, and
terrorism. This course satisfies Binghamton University's Composition
(C) and Social Science (N) General Education requirements. There
are no prerequisites.
Required Texts
Collier, George A. with Elizabeth Lowery Quaratiello. 1999 [1994].
Basta! Land and the Zapatista Rebellion in Chiapas. Oakland:
Food First.
Malkki, Liisa H. 1995. Purity and Exile: Violence, Memory, and
National Cosmology among Hutu Refugees in Tanzania. Chicago
and London: The University of Chicago Press.
Course Readings
The required books for this course are available for purchase
at the Campus Bookstore. Copies of each are also on 2-hour reserve
at the Bartle Library reserve reading room (indicated as [on reserve]).
In addition to the required books, further required readings as
indicated on the syllabus are available either in the library's
reserve room, in the library's journal holdings, or electronically
([avail. elec.]). Some of the assigned readings may be journal articles
available electronically through the library's web page.
Course Requirements and Evaluation
You are required to complete the assigned readings prior to the
class period under which they are listed. Be prepared to contribute
to class discussions and small group work. The primary workload
for this course consists of class discussion and writing assignments,
much of which will be based on readings. In this course students
will be evaluated based on discussion and in-class writing assignments,
reading and lecture summaries, essay exams, and a research paper,
which includes two drafts, a peer review workshop, and a summary
presentation the last week of class (to be discussed in more detail).
Discussion and exploratory writing assignments are an
important component of this course, intended to facilitate engagement
with the readings and lecture material. Please note that participation
in classroom exercises and discussion is a significant portion of
your grade.
Reading/lecture summaries will be assigned during class
and due the following day (as indicated on the reading schedule).
These assignments will involve writing a 300-500 word analytical
summary that integrates key questions and ideas from readings and
lectures, and then concludes with a question. You will have the
option to handing in up to two extra summaries throughout the course
for 5 bonus points each. You will need to arrange this with me ahead
of time. No other extra-credit is available in this course.
The three essay exams will be take-home writing assignments
involving a 3 to 5-page response to an exam question given in class.
To be discussed in more detail later.
The final paper will involve an outline and series of
drafts, including a peer review workshop and an instructor review.
You will need to start thinking about this paper and working on
it as soon as possible. Will we discuss this paper extensively in
class, and you will be required to meet with me by the second week
regarding potential topics. You will also be expected to discuss
your project in class at various points during the term and give
a summary presentation the last week.
|
| Grades will be assigned as follows (200 points total): |
| |
Discussion and exploratory writing assignments: |
20 points |
|
| |
Reading/lecture summaries: |
20 points |
|
| |
Three essay exams: |
60 points |
|
| |
Final paper: |
100 points |
|
| |
Outline (10 points) |
| |
Draft 1, for peer review, 5-7 pages (15 points) |
| |
Peer review workshop (10 points) |
| |
Draft 2, for instructor review, 7-10 pages (15 points) |
| |
Final draft, 10-12 pages (50 points) |
|
|
Other Course Policies
All writing assignments completed outside of class should be typed--double
spaced, 12 pt. font, Times New Roman, 1 inch margins, black ink,
and page numbers.
Academic dishonesty, plagiarism, or misuse of another person's
academic work, as discussed in University guidelines, will not be
tolerated.
Attendance is required and you are expected to submit all work
on time. Assignments will not be accepted electronically (email,
attachment, disk, etc).
Reading and Assignment Schedule REVISED:
(Details of assignments will be discussed in class.)
Section 1: Anthropology, Social Change, and the Crisis of
Ethnography
|
| 5/27 |
Ethnographic Film: "N!ai, the Story of a !Kung
Woman" |
| 5/28 |
Rosaldo, Renato. 1989. Culture and Truth: The
Remaking of Social Analysis. Read
Ch. 1: 'The Erosion of Classic Norms' (pp. 25-45) [on reserve] |
| 5/29 |
Rosaldo. Ch. 3: 'Imperialist Nostalgia', 68-87 [on
reserve]
Collier, Introduction (pp. 1-14) |
Section 2: Capitalism, Globalization, and the Crisis of the State
Case Study: The Zapatista Rebellion
| 5/30 |
First reading/lecture summary due today. |
| 6/2 |
Subcomandante Marcos, "A Storm and a Prophecy."
[on reserve]
Nash, June. 2001. "Globalization and the cultivation of peripheral
vision." Anthropology Today 17(4):15-22.
See also: http://www.ezln.org, website
of the Zapatista Army of National Liberation. |
| 6/3 |
Collier, Basta!, Introduction and Ch. 1
Ethnographic Film: "The Kayapó, Out of the Forest"
|
| 6/4 |
Skim Collier, Ch. 2
Try to read all of Collier Ch. 3. |
| 6/5 |
Finish Collier Ch. 3 and read Ch. 4. Begin Ch. 5;
finish if possible.
Optional: Hayden, Tom. 2003. "Seeking a New Globalism
in Chiapas" The Nation.
on reserve and available at: http://www.thenation.com/doc.mhtml?i=20030407&s=hayden |
| 6/9 |
Finish Collier: Chs. 6, 7, and Epilogue.
Prospectus of paper expected today. |
| 6/10 |
Video: " A Place Called Chiapas" |
Section 3: The Symbolics of Social (Dis)Order
Case Study: Refugees, Violence, and Collective Memory
| 6/11 |
Essay exam 1 due today.
Malkki, Liisa H. 1995. Purity and Exile. 'Introduction' (pp.
1-18)
Optional: Kearney, Michael. 1998. "Transnationalism in
California and Mexico at the End of Empire." [on reserve] |
| 6/12 |
Malkki, part of Ch. 1 (pp.38-51) and begin reading
Ch. 2 (pp. 52-104) |
| 6/16 |
Finish Malkki Ch. 2, and start reading Ch. 3 (105-152)
First draft of final paper due today. |
| 6/17 |
Continue Malkki Ch. 3
Peer review workshop. |
| 6/18 |
Malkki. Ch 4 (pp. 153-196) |
| 6/19 |
Continue with Malkki, Ch 4
Malkki Ch. 5 (pp. 197-231) |
| |
Optional: Malkki Ch. 6 (pp. 232-258); Postscript
(259-298) |
| 6/20 |
Second draft of paper due to me by 4 p.m. |
| 6/23 |
Essay exam 2 due today.
Ethnographic film: "The Triumph of Evil: Rwandan Genocide"
|
Section 4: Crisis, 'Real' and 'Imagined'
| 6/24 |
Lutz, Catherine. 2002. "Making War at Home
in the United States: Militarization and the Current Crisis."
American Anthropologist 104(3):723-735. [avail. elec.]
Mattingly, Cheryl et. al. 2002. Narrating September 11: Race, Gender,
and the Play of Cultural Identities. American Anthropologist
104(3):743-753. [avail. elec.] |
| 6/25 |
Aretxaga, Begona. 2001. "Terror as a thrill:
First thoughts on the 'war on terrorism'." Anthropological
Quarterly 75(1):138-150. [avail. elec.] |
| 6/25 |
Essay exam 3 due today. |
| 6/26 |
Ethnographic Film: TBA |
| 6/27 |
Final drafts of papers due by 4 p.m. Note: late
papers may not be graded. |
Anth 264: Cultures and Crisis: Course Objectives |
|
This course has three primary objectives:
Content objective:
We begin with the proposition that 'crisis' is a useful theme
for thinking about and analyzing contemporary forms of social
change, struggle and conflict. We attempt to develop an understanding
of crisis as both a social and symbolic ('cultural') phenomenon.
Further, we will explore three related questions or problems:
|
| · |
Crisis is a social and cultural phenomenon; the meaning
of a given crisis is always culturally constructed; the experience
of crisis in the modern world is commonly mediated by its
representation.
|
| · |
We consider both 'real' and 'imagined' crisis,
that is, the event identified as crisis and the perception
of crisis. |
| · |
The theme of crisis may help us understand
notions of social order and disorder, and also forms of social
control and configurations of power and inequality. |
|
Social science objective:
We attempt to develop a 'cultural anthropological' perspective
on the above problems. We conceptualize cultural anthropology
as a historically or culturally situated form of knowledge
production. As such, the field is not simply a reservoir of
'correct' information, but a way of knowing and perceiving
the world.
|
| · |
Hence, we engage anthropological knowledge
in a 'dialogic' rather than 'informational' manner. That is,
we approach knowledge, and our engagement with knowledge through
reading and writing, as dialogic (that is, there are always
multiple and opposing voices at play), contingent, ambiguous,
and tentative. |
| · |
We explore the problems and potentials of 'ethnography'
as a research method and genre of writing. |
| · |
We will undertake qualitative research projects
targeted at understanding the interplay of 'real' and 'imagined'
crisis (to be explained). Rather than choosing a research 'topic',
I encourage you to explore a particular question or problem
related to the theme of 'crisis'. |
Composition objective:
We will use writing as a way to actively engage the course readings
and lectures. We will consider writing as a 'thinking process',
developing ideas primarily through two forms of writing:
|
| · |
Exploratory writing, or informal writing done
without revision primarily to help generate, extend, deepen,
and clarify thinking. |
| · |
Formal or organized writing, such as assigned
reading summaries, essay exams, and research papers. We focus
here on writing as a process of revision. Revision is not merely
'more editing', but a process of further discovery, development,
and modification of ideas. Drafting should exhibit the recursive
process of thinking and working with ideas.
|
|
| Course Research Project and Paper
|
Objective:
Using qualitative research methods and interpretive analysis
our objective is to explore and further develop the broad
theoretical premise that there is a dialectical interplay
between 'real' and 'imagined' crisis.
The problem:
The central theme of this course is the relationship between
culture and crisis, and we are looking broadly at forms of
social crisis, conflict, struggle, and change. Rather than
having you choose 'topics' to research and write on, I would
like you to explore a question, case study, or problem related
to a specific theme we are developing in this course: You
are to explore the interplay between 'real' and 'imagined'
crisis. This can mean crisis as it is 'experienced' and 'represented',
or 'crisis' and its 'representation,' or the 'perception'
of crisis. In some cases the crisis may only exist at the
level of representations, such as an imagined crisis, which
is manifested as fear or anxiety. The focus here is on the
social event and its meanings.
An important idea is that the experience of crisis is
always shaped by 'culture'. How is crisis rendered culturally
and symbolically meaningful? How is it represented in a particular
manner? What do these representations suggest about the threat
of disorder and conceptions of social order? How do representations
shape the experience of crisis?
A wide range of topics may be pursued as you explore this
broad research problem. You have a great deal of flexibility
in locating an example to observe and then formulating a research
question to gather 'data' on.
Research and writing as interrelated process:
You are to pursue 'qualitative' social science research methods
and analysis in writing this paper. Broadly speaking, qualitative
analysis refers to the non-numerical examination and interpretation
of observations, for the purpose of drawing out underlying
meanings and patterns of analysis. Qualitative research can
include such methods as open-ended interviews, narrative analysis,
participant observation, or a review of existing literature
on a subject. We are gathering 'data' in order to develop
an interpretive analysis. We will discuss this more in class.
We are pursuing research and writing as an interrelated
process. This process is 'question-' or 'thesis-driven'. This
means you must begin by thinking of an interesting example
of the interplay between real and imagined crisis, and then
formulate a question to guide your research. We will then
develop our research through a series of stages.
Stages of qualitative research we will pursue:
1. Finding a problem or series of questions that interests
you. Start thinking about this immediately.
2. Formulating a research problem, question, or thesis to
explore and govern your project.
3. Designing a method of data collection.
4. Undertaking research. This should be done relatively soon,
between June 2 and June 13.
5. Reviewing data for patterns or regularities. What emerges
from your observations? How do your 'observations' or data
articulate with the initial research problem?
6. Interpreting 'data' or findings
7. Developing an answer or response to the initial research
problem, question, or thesis. (Note: A rough draft of your
paper is expected by June 16.)
8. Rethinking and reworking your analysis through writing
a series of drafts.
Stages of writing (each will be talked about in more detail
in class):
1. Begin thinking about a potential set of problems or questions,
cases, examples, and so on. Write some notes to yourself.
Think about things that you are familiar with and that are
interesting to you.
2. Talk to each other about what you're thinking. Each student
is required to meet with me individually the week of June
2 to June 6 to talk about your project.
3. An outline of the question/problem that is driving your
research and how you expect to develop the ideas behind the
problem is expected by June 9.
4. A rough draft is expected by June 16. Focus on getting
the ideas down on paper in preliminary form. Peer review workshop.
5. A second draft is due by June 20. Focus on reformulating
your ideas and revising your text into a more readable form.
I will read and comment on this draft.
6. Final draft is due by June 27. It should include all previous
drafts and outlines and a record of your research.
|
|
|